85 replies to this topic

[Elsie]

Listen to When I'm gone or haylie's song, mockingbird, beautiful, despicable, soldier, stan, the way i am, rock bottom, bad meets evil, till i collapse, underground, sing for the moment and there is no finish to this. then maybe you'll have more respect for him.

Then listen to Kim and lose all that respect 8-/

[ohmr]

lol

[D-Bomb]

I love Kim and 97 Bonnie & Clyde. The Slim Shady and Marshall Mathers LPs shit on everything since but him being vulgar is hardly a fair argument at this point.
Rihanna's Rehab came out in 2008. Not the same subject matter.
Em's Relapse is just horrible so thats the "you owe everyone." Even he admits its a POS

[Dani14]

Then listen to Kim and lose all that respect 8-/

One song can't make me lose respect. But anyway i love the track. And it's just a song.

[LegendJJ]

I love Kim and 97 Bonnie & Clyde. The Slim Shady and Marshall Mathers LPs shit on everything since but him being vulgar is hardly a fair argument at this point.
Rihanna's Rehab came out in 2008. Not the same subject matter.
Em's Relapse is just horrible so thats the "you owe everyone." Even he admits its a POS

Trust me Marshall was definately lying when he said Relapse was a POS. I'm positive he loved it and only said he hated it to win back fans for Recovery

And it is silly people imply being vulgar makes a person bad....even "conscience" rappers(I hate using that word since most musicians are conscious of the music they make) curse.

As for Rihanna's rehab....I checked info out on it and it said it was recorded in January of 07.....Amy's album came out 2 months earlier in October of 06. I haven't heard rihanna's rehab song...

Does the message sound the same as Amy's??:amyshock:

Whether or not Rihanna copied Amy....I don't know what she meant by how "you owe me"....since it wasn't exactly Rihanna's biggest songs

[Elsie]

And it is silly people imply being vulgar makes a person bad....even "conscience" rappers(I hate using that word since most musicians are conscious of the music they make) curse.

It is silly. But I don't really see anyone implying that here. Unless you think cursing is that song's main issue.
I personally don't have a problem with people judging Amy on Rehab - their loss. Why shouldn't we judge artists based off singles? Most people are too lazy to go over every single artist's discography to find a deeper meaning to them and instead choose to judge them off from what they're served. Their loss or gain... so who cares.

Oh and Rihanna's Rehab is actually a decent song. It was my favourite off that album, not really the same theme as Amy's. LOL But I love Rihanna so I might be a bit biased.

Edited by Elsie, 01 September 2011 - 09:09 PM.

[ohmr]

Does the message sound the same as Amy's??:amyshock:

Whether or not Rihanna copied Amy....I don't know what she meant by how "you owe me"....since it wasn't exactly Rihanna's biggest songs

No. It's more of a metaphorical term used in the song. It's about not being able to get over or give up someone.

[Cariena]

I've said it for years Eminem is a fucking cunt.

[LegendJJ]

I've said it for years Eminem is a fucking cunt.

:'-(

[D-Bomb]

Trust me Marshall was definately lying when he said Relapse was a POS. I'm positive he loved it and only said he hated it to win back fans for Recovery

And it is silly people imply being vulgar makes a person bad....even "conscience" rappers(I hate using that word since most musicians are conscious of the music they make) curse.

As for Rihanna's rehab....I checked info out on it and it said it was recorded in January of 07.....Amy's album came out 2 months earlier in October of 06. I haven't heard rihanna's rehab song...

Does the message sound the same as Amy's??:amyshock:

Whether or not Rihanna copied Amy....I don't know what she meant by how "you owe me"....since it wasn't exactly Rihanna's biggest songs

Just head over to YouTube if you're curious. As for as Relapse, I hated it immediately. Beautiful is the only thing I bother with.

[LegendJJ]

Then listen to Kim and lose all that respect 8-/

Hailie this is for you, Whitney and Alaina too
I STILL LOve your mother that will never change,

Think about her every day, we just could never get it together

Hey, wish there was a better way, for me to say it

But I swear on everything, I'd do anything for her on any day



Anyway......I can understand Amy being upset at Eminem.....but I just don't get why she brought up Rihanna. Even if Rihanna got inspiration from Amy, Amy should know that the song isn't similar to her song that much.