amy and judaism...

hey guys! i’m curious if anyone knows if amy practiced judaism while growing up. i know her background is Jewish but i didn’t know if she went to synagogue/temple when younger. did her parents have her go to hebrew school?? hehe, that would have been cute. also, out of curiousity how many of her fans here are Jewish? i am! represent. hehehe. =)

Not Jewish but if you wade through some old article thread posts (during the Frank era) you should find when she speaks about taking part in some traditional elements but does not consider her self really religious.

thanks! are there any jews here? just wondering is all!

I’m, but not pure :slight_smile: My grandmothers mother was jewish, but father no. So my grandmother is a bit jewish, my mather is a bit jewish and I’m a bit jewish :smiley:

Im not jewish Felt like posting that coz it seems like no one is really answering this thread and saying if they are jewish or not!

I’m not jewish either. I’m nothing. Well I am officially catholic I guess, but well yeah…

Im not religious either Sarah . . . I was christened, but never been religious in the slightest, only been to Chruch when the school used to make us!

I’m not religious too, don’t go to church, but I have faith, I believe in God.

Actually, according to Judaism, you are completely 100% Jewish.

That’s because being Jewish or not is maternally passed down. If your maternal grandmother’s mother was Jewish, then your grandmother was Jewish and your mother and you…unless you opted out and converted to something else.

suestev07 is right, it depends on your mothers’ religion, not your daddys [= but i aint even christened ! although it’s always nice to believe in something isn’t it [=

But my mother was grown up like Christian, I was grown up like Christian, and my mothers mother was grown up like christian, because her mother who was 100% Jew died after gave birth to my grandmother. So I think I am Christian, but have Jewish blood. Right?

ohh right yess, that makes sense [=

absolutely; your family obviously opted out and “converted” to Christianity.

Historically, a lot of Jewish families did that when things were rough for Jews in certain geographic areas…especially if they had the added “convenience” of having a non-Jewish father.

And, people just opted out because they made the choice to follow the Dad’s religion.

yay for religions, regardless what you practice lol

I am not Jewish. However, I have been told I look Jewish - and I know that must be right because the first time I met my boyfriend’s parents for dinner, his mum said “OMG, I bought pork! Does she eat pork?” My boyf found it so very funny and told his mum that I was a catholic - much to her relief. As for faith - I am not a practicing catholic. I was forced to practice when I was a kid at school - but since I’ve become an adult - I don’t go to church except for funerals, weddings and christenings!

i bet ya beautiful then! hehehe

I am a goy, and one thing I really dont like about Judaism is that separation of people into sorts. Like you can’t cheat or make losses to a Jew, but then you are more than welcome to do that to a Christian or to a Muslim, and othe cases of discrimination of goys according to the Talmud. But then, I despise every sort of religion, so it’s nothing personal. I could go on and critize every religion in the world.

Nope… just a lot of hungarian. I’ve got a lot of other stuff in me too. My Nana came from england about 80 yrs ago. Then my Other Grandma and Grandpa came from Hungry. And my Nana’s hubby came from Germany when he was two. I’ve got some Irish and Native American in me. And some French by law. Others too…

Here we go…we get snippets about this religion or that religion and take them as truths…

Josh, I respect you and you may be right, but would you kindly let us know where it says that “you can’t cheat or make losses to a Jew, but then you are more than welcome to do that to a Christian or to a Muslim, and other cases of discrimination of goys according to the Talmud”, and is it a credible place where you got this info from?

Some things that we grow up with are untruths, and promoted as generalities, or stereotypes, because of ignorance (I don’t mean stupidity, I mean just not knowing the facts.) Like I said above, you may be right, but show us.

It seems incongruous to me that on this forum we always quote where we got our information from when it’s a story about Amy, which, after all, is really and truly only about entertainment, ( I don’t mean to minimize entertainment; I know she’s very important to us - we love Amy to pieces and really care for her viscerally - I’m addicted to her, just like a lot of us here) but when it comes to slagging an entire mainstream religion we feel free to spout anything…seems just like the tabloids that we detest, no?!

Had to get this off my chest. Thanks.:shrug::wink:

Edit: btw, there are multiple religions in my family, which you may have guessed.

Actually I was thinking about it. But I just dont remember. It was a Russian translation of some semi-religious Jewish book, I don’t even recall the title of it. I remember when it became public some two years ago, there was an uproar in the Russian parliament about it, but I don’t think they passed anything about it ultimately, coz the rabbies were arguing that it’s a historic text etc. and doesn’t necessarily reflect the current reality. It looked like a code of conduct for me. I will try to find the title of the book and the link, I am 100% sure it must be available somewhere on the net, and most probably even in English. Like I said, I read parts of it in Russian which I don’t think you can. If I don’t manage to find an English copy, I will try to back-translate some of the most controversial points.

I knew it was a fickle topic when I made my post above, and I would like to stress that I don’t represent any religion at all and I don’t see no value in any religion. I hope I’m seeing every religion from a pretty neutral point of view. No offense to the Jewish people, I’d criticize the Roman Catholic church as well, if it was about them this time.