He sounds like one of those elitists who can’t like anybody with more than 10 fans because that would not make him indie but you damn well know he sings along to Back to Black when nobody is looking.
"I bought Winehouse’s first album, “Frank,” in 2004 at a Heathrow Airport music kiosk. I listened to it on the plane home and dropped it in a garbage can on the way to baggage claim. “Frank” was Winehouse being showy before her voice could raise the curtain: she sounds thin, misses notes, and lacks any specific character.
his loss!
Malaroda:
"He seems to be analyzing it too much…
agreed…her voice, her voice, ahh, her voice…it’s lovely…
Definitely a bit snooty, but a still an interesting read nonetheless.
That’s for sure. As for him throwing Frank into the garbage - I don’t know if I believe that - I think he wrote that for effect. Whatever - I can’t stand that ‘hipper than thou’ atttitude.
I like the pic that came with the interview - I don’t think I’ve seen this one before:
Amy Winehouse in The New Yorker? Gimme a break. B2B is not an album that takes a while to grow on you, if you’re not stuck on analyzing it that is. Disagreed with everything said about Frank. The title sounds like something Rolling Stone came up with. For the few passages that captured me, I think the article is rubbish.
The New Yorker has a reputation that even if you discovered a cure for AIDS, they’d still find something to criticize. The ending of the article struck me as being in poor taste:
“It [her mush-mouthed singing style] may be neither—it is Winehouse’s signature, and if she can detach it from the past and keep writing songs like “Rehab” there will be nothing surprising about having her around for a long time. Other than having her around.”
It’s well worth purchasing this week’s New Yorker, by the way. Although the article is snooty, there’s a full page pic of Amy (as it is above). It’s awesome!!!