"When the Grammys celebrate their big 50th birthday party in February, the main dish they serve could well be controversy.
On Thursday morning, when the academy reveals who’s nominated for the year’s prizes, the name most likely to be mentioned early and often belongs to someone less noted for music of late than for rubber-room-ready performances, outrageous public comments and frequent accusations of drug abuse.
Yes, folks, we’re talking about Miss “No Rehab” herself, Amy Winehouse.
In fact, the news for this distressed singer just got worse. Over the weekend, she was photographed wandering the street by her London home in a bleary-eyed state, barefoot and dressed only in a bra and jeans. Her mother-in-law has claimed she’s taking "more drugs than ever. "
Though Winehouse clearly rates as music’s biggest screwup since a certain woman who shaved her head this year, voters can’t ignore the fact that she’s also music’s biggest breakout star of '07 and a confirmed critic love magnet.
Winehouse’s U.S. debut, “Back to Black,” has sold nearly 1.5 million copies in a market where a successful new artist is lucky to move one fourth that. And every aspect of her - from her saucy voice to her “Elvira: Mistress of the Dark” makeup and hair - positions her as an icon in the making.
Her Billie Holiday-like back story doesn’t hurt in that regard.
The question remains, however: Will voters feel like enablers if they celebrate Winehouse at a time when she just canceled her latest tour due to “exhaustion.”
If the voters go heavily for her (fairly likely in categories like Album, Song and Record of the Year, and all but assured in the slot of Best New Artist), they’ll maintain last year’s penchant for making big-time news. In 2006, the top awards went to the Dixie Chicks for songs that defiantly responded to the bashing they took in the wake of their anti-Bush rant.
On the other hand, if the academy rejects Winehouse, it would rob this year’s nominations of their only possible spice. Outside of her, the most likely contenders couldn’t be more snooze-inducing. Many will probably get in only because Grammy members tend to vote for the same, safely respectable names over and over, no matter what product they put out.
This time that means they’re likely to go for Norah Jones’ “Not Too Late” and Kanye West’s “Graduation” - two unobjectionable and huge-selling albums that did little to advance their stars’ artistry. Career or cultural highs, they’re not.
…We’ll find out who wins the actual awards on Feb. 10. In the meantime, here’s a breakdown of who may turn up in the running:
ALBUM OF THE YEAR
Most likelies: Amy Winehouse, “Back to Black”; Bruce Springsteen, “Magic”; Paul McCartney, “Memory Almost Full”; Kanye West, “Graduation”; Norah Jones, “Not Too Late.”
Could bes: John Fogerty, “Revival”; Joni Mitchell, “Shine”; Maroon 5, “It Won’t Be Soon Before Long”; White Stripes, “Icky Thump”; the Arcade Fire, “The Neon Bible.”
Left-fielders: Soundtrack of “Dreamgirls” (if voters remember back as far as last December); Feist, “The Reminder” (never underestimate the power of a critically admired star who broke through with an iPod commercial).
SONG AND/OR RECORD OF THE YEAR
Most likelies: “Radio Nowhere,” Bruce Springsteen; “Rehab,” Amy Winehouse; “Listen,” Beyoncé (from the “Dreamgirls” soundtrack).
Could bes: “Thinking About You,” Norah Jones (her biggest radio hit since “Don’t Know Why”); “Stonger,” Kanye West; “Makes Me Wonder,” Maroon 5; “Lost Without You,” Robin Thicke (the first white star to go No. 1 on R&B radio since George Michael); "Umbrella, " Rihanna (if only because hers was the biggest song of the summer, amid swill like “That’s Why I’m Hot” and “Party Like a Rock Star”).
Left-fielder: “1 2 3 4,” Feist.
BEST NEW ARTIST
Shoo-in: Amy Winehouse.
Other likelies: Mika; Feist (even though she’s on her fourth album, this category counts the year the artist broke); Lily Allen; Paolo Nutini; Taylor Swift.
Left-fielders: T-Pain; Sean Kingston.